For a long time I've been hearing people talk about how bad Mangagamer butchers their releases with missing CG, features, or voice acting that was once present in the JPN versions. Some of these include: changing music in Higurashi and shortening the length of their new VN "If My Heart Had Wings" (also removing CGs that were in the JPN release). I know personally I've noticed some pretty bad flubs when it comes to their release of Kira*Kira (iOS) with the voices being mixed up and even a line of dialogue being left untranslated (these issues were later fixed through patches).
In regards to "If My Heart Had Wings", I'd like to maybe purchase it in the future, but if it is missing a ton of content (someone said it might be missing 30 hours - though I'm pretty sure that might be inaccurate) I'd rather not waste my money on a butchered product.
While I understand all of these issues (and their recent release might have been about decisions from the actual translators Moenovel), I was wondering what other people think about Mangagamer. Are they generally reviled like I seem to hear all the time, or is it just Internet hate propelled out of control?