Exactly, Galaxy Angel seems like the most accurate representation of art style I don't like. I don't wanna be rude or anything, I even think the story might be good, but the art style is not appealing to me. It makes me feel like I am looking at something made 10-20 years ago. It's the same like watching DBZ/One Piece now, I can't bring myself to watch it cause it looks horrible to me even though I know it's amazing. Yes I know, I am weird, but I can't bring myself to being sucked into the story if I don't see something that looks realistic or polished. If you look at Sunrider Liberation Day compared to Galaxy Angel, you can clearly see that difference . It looks realistic, polished, 2010+ anime like and stuff. So maybe I am looking for something 2010+ anime like.
Oh Seinarukana, I played it. It was really good, the art style was good and story kept me entertained for a long time (gameplay elements were interesting a lot too). Sorry for not saying that, I've read/played some VNs but not many, just some major ones. Kamidori, Seinarukana, Sunrider were really good ones (sunrider would be way above them in ranking though, I really loved it story/character/emotion wise), art appealing and story wise good (even though Kamidori's story was kinda simplistic, but still good thanks to characters). Maji de Watashini Koi Shinasai was not bad also but would need better story to be awesome (art is really nice and characters were diverse and cool) . Bunny black's art style was superb too (gameplay interesting enough to get through but story and H element way too off for me, it seemed way too focused on H element that other things were garbage... I'd like story driven with some ero in it, but if it was just ecchi (or no ero at all) I wouldn't mind if there was great emotional story.)
Sorry for being so picky, if it wasn't that hard to find something, I wouldn't be asking here But I appreciate your help a lot guys.
Summary: New-ish Anime like action VN/Eroge (preferably with gameplay) with great emotional story and characters you can sympathize with (feel their emotions... still feeling them from Sunrider when something happened to your crew).