(putting all the quotes under a spoiler. sorry it took long!)
Thanks for your recommendations! I remember trying to read the first part of Dies Irae, but it just wasn't for me. Action isn't something I truly enjoy if it isn't just for some specific parts, and that's the reason I put Fate H/A over the original VN. I'm definitely interested in Ayakashibito though! I will make sure to add it to my list
Thanks for your recommendations too! I'm not really a fan of the male protagonist + an all female cast combination though x_x I've heard wonders of Muv Luv but I don't know if I could put up with having two previous games mainly centered in romance... I could say the same for some others you recommended. I don't want to judge ahead of time but I'd like to know if it's really worth it despite my dislike, I can always change my mind!
Planetarian and G-senjou no Maou seem to be up my alley, I'll be checking them out Oh and maybe it's just me but I can't find any *eden information (probably because of the asterisk)
I don't know if you went inside my mind to know exactly what I'm searching for since I was really vague, because I'm definitely interested in ALL of these!! I'm so excited to read them, but so sorry at the same time since I'm in the middle of finals but I should start making room for VNs with all the recommendations above too
-----------
First of all sorry if I seem petty in those responses!! I thought it was better to let you know my opinion since you took the time to write really interesting recoomendations and also add a description to each of them, it was really helpful and I can't thank you enough for that, I didn't know half of these existed. See you next time!