Haven't really watched the School Days anime (don't flame), but I've played the entirety of the VN. Makoto is still undoubtedly and unbelievably irritating. The only routes that seem replayable are the bad ends (not surprisingly, those are my only saves)
I know there are ways on how to make an indecisive character look nice on anime (I'm looking at you, High School DXD, I.S., Campione), but Makoto takes it all.
Oh wait... Takeya from DearS
Tch, it'll be a long night