VirginSmasher Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015 (edited) What are your guy's favorite heroine group in visual novels? What I mean is what game has the overall best heroines. List your favorite heroines from the game as well. My favorite group of heroines is a tie between Majikoi and Kanon. My favorite heroines from each of those games are Mayucchi and Shiori. Edited October 22, 2015 by VirginSmasher Quote
nohman Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015 Without regards to route quality, I'd probably say Grisaia's cast. All of them cracked me up, more than any other visual novel. Quote
VirginSmasher Posted October 22, 2015 Author Posted October 22, 2015 Without regards to route quality, I'd probably say Grisaia's cast. All of them cracked me up, more than any other visual novel.Grisaia's heroine cast is really good. It's definitely up in my favorites. Quote
Deep Blue Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015 (edited) katawa shoujo without any doubt and by far has the best heroines (sorry shizune but except for you  ) Edited October 22, 2015 by Deep Blue Quote
nohman Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015 (sorry shizune but except for you  ) Next to Lilly, Shizune was my favorite heroine in KS - again, not speaking to route quality. I'll see you behind the school at 3 PM to fight you. Quote
VirginSmasher Posted October 22, 2015 Author Posted October 22, 2015  Next to Lilly, Shizune was my favorite heroine in KS - again, not speaking to route quality. I'll see you behind the school at 3 PM to fight you. Hey, I'll back you up. Shizune was great. I'm so tired of hearing, "Shizune sucks, Lilly is best", even though Lilly is admittedly pretty good as well.Probably gonna have to go with Grisaia's heroines as my favorite, and Majikoi's in second place. It's pretty hard to beat Grisaia's cast, they're just so good. I'm sure nobody will be able to guess my favorite Grisaia heroine  My favorite Majikoi heroine is, without a doubt, Wanko, with Miyako coming in second.Shizune was a great heroine. The one I remember least was the girl without any arms. The only reason I remember the girl with metal legs is for that lube scene (Sorry if I don't remember their names, I haven't played KS since August of last year). Quote
Eclipsed Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015 Ye, u can't really beat dem Grisaia heroines    Not technically a VN, but I also really like the interactions b/w Hyperdimension Neptunia's CPUs & Candidates. Quote
Deep Blue Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015 (edited) wow wow let me explain first I have that right !!! , I didnt think her character was bad just really reaaaaaally badly developed, there was a lot of potential in her route but sadly it wasn't exploited enough or i should say at all, most of her route was about Misha :/Honestly the part when you are in the roof watching the fireworks and the dialogue you have with her, that part was one of the best scenes in the novel, sadly it was the only one Edited October 22, 2015 by Deep Blue Kawasumi 1 Quote
nohman Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015  Hey, I'll back you up. Shizune was great. I'm so tired of hearing, "Shizune sucks, Lilly is best", even though Lilly is admittedly pretty good as well.While her route did have more than its fair share of problems, more than any other route + ending (good or bad) in the game, her bad ending was the one that hit me with the most feels. That CG man...That alone put it above Emi and Hanako's route in my book. Quote
Fred the Barber Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015 I've gotta go with the Rewrite cast. 4/5 really solid lead characters is a pretty good record. Keep in mind my VN experience isn't that broad, though. I haven't played Grisaia, so that's not even in the running for me; I have played Majikoi, though, and would definitely pick Rewrite's heroines over Majikoi's. Obviously my preference is completely subjective, so if you disagree, fite me. Quote
VirginSmasher Posted October 22, 2015 Author Posted October 22, 2015 I've gotta go with the Rewrite cast. 4/5 really solid lead characters is a pretty good record. Keep in mind my VN experience isn't that broad, though. I haven't played Grisaia, so that's not even in the running for me; I have played Majikoi, though, and would definitely pick Rewrite's heroines over Majikoi's. Obviously my preference is completely subjective, so if you disagree, fite me.Haven't played Rewrite yet, but Key VNs tend to have an amazing cast of heroines based on the 3 I've played. Quote
TexasDice Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015 My favorite female casts are usually the ones I don't actually want to date, because they feel so much like real friends to me. That applies exclusively to casts which interact a lot with the player and amongst themselves, in order to form an immersive group experience (Grisaia, Majikoi or Deardrops).In conclusion, I am unable to order these characters in any sort of list, because I like them all equally personality-wise. I could only rank them for superficial reasons, like appearance, voice or route quality, which kind of defeats my point. tl;dr: If I like all heroines to a point, at which I don't want to romance any of them, then it is my favorite cast. If one girl is just better (or worse) than all the others, I can't consider the entire cast as favored.   nohman 1 Quote
nohman Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015 My favorite female casts are usually the ones I don't actually want to date, because they feel so much like real friends to me. That applies exclusively to casts which interact a lot with the player and amongst themselves, in order to form an immersive group experience (Grisaia, Majikoi or Deardrops).+1 for Deardrops. I had briefly considered mentioning it myself, but Grisaia won out for me. Still that game's up there when it comes to a solid, varied cast of likable characters. Quote
TexasDice Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015 +1 for Deardrops. I had briefly considered mentioning it myself, but Grisaia won out for me. Still that game's up there when it comes to a solid, varied cast of likable characters.I actually thought about not mentioning Deardrops for a quite while, simply because of how important Eiji is to the band. Quote
mjriedstra Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015 Grisaia and Majikoi are both excellent and it's hard to argue with either choice. Michiru and Wanko are roughly tied for my favorite two heroines in any game, and in terms of full cast I think both games have almost no weaknesses.Honorable mentions are Clannad, Da Capo II ... and FSN. Rin, Saber, Ilya, Sakura ... they're all good. Quote
storyteller Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015 Haruka ni Aogi, Uruwashi no - Tonoko.Otoboku2? - Kaori Quote
nohman Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015 +1 for Deardrops. I had briefly considered mentioning it myself, but Grisaia won out for me. Still that game's up there when it comes to a solid, varied cast of likable characters.I actually thought about not mentioning Deardrops for a quite while, simply because of how important Eiji is to the band.I'm confused; what are you talking about? Eiji is the best heroine in the game. TexasDice 1 Quote
Stormwolf Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015 +1 for Deardrops. I had briefly considered mentioning it myself, but Grisaia won out for me. Still that game's up there when it comes to a solid, varied cast of likable characters.I actually thought about not mentioning Deardrops for a quite while, simply because of how important Eiji is to the band.I'm confused; what are you talking about? Eiji is the best heroine in the game.While not a heroine, he's definitely the best character in the game  Well, he might just tie with Chika! TexasDice 1 Quote
VirginSmasher Posted October 22, 2015 Author Posted October 22, 2015 Haven't played DearDrops but I've heard from my friend Shaun that it's good. Quote
monkeysrumble Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015 It's got be Grisaia. I love every heroine in the game and Michiru is just too damn perfect. Quote
VirginSmasher Posted October 22, 2015 Author Posted October 22, 2015 It's got be Grisaia. I love every heroine in the game and Michiru is just too damn perfect.Michiru is the best tsundere I've encountered in a VN so far. Quote
StormShaun Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015 That is a really hard question. At least for myself.I mean, I have many heroines I like, but they all come from different visual novels.If I have to go for a group of heroines I like, it would have to be the Majikoi series.Not just the original.Not just S,But the whole damn series.I know, it sounds like I'm cheating, but both additions have heroines I really, really like. Not just from the original group, but from the top-tier class and others.Most likely because Majikoi does well when it comes to characters, it has a load of variety, which I simply love. Even if I have to choose Kazuko and Kokoro as my main heroines from the two.Now this makes me pumped for Majikoi A.  Haven't played DearDrops but I've heard from my friend Shaun that it's good.It is good, but I found Kira*Kira to be so much better.In terms of other aspects, that is. In terms of "group of heroines", it is pretty damn good in that part. Still, you'll have to play it for yourself, especially since fans of both games have their reasons.Also, yes, they are most certainly right about Eiji. For Eiji is love, Eiji is life. Quote
VirginSmasher Posted October 22, 2015 Author Posted October 22, 2015 That is a really hard question. At least for myself.I mean, I have many heroines I like, but they all come from different visual novels.If I have to go for a group of heroines I like, it would have to be the Majikoi series.Not just the original.Not just S,But the whole damn series.I know, it sounds like I'm cheating, but both additions have heroines I really, really like. Not just from the original group, but from the top-tier class and others.Most likely because Majikoi does well when it comes to characters, it has a load of variety, which I simply love. Even if I have to choose Kazuko and Kokoro as my main heroines from the two.Now this makes me pumped for Majikoi A.  Haven't played DearDrops but I've heard from my friend Shaun that it's good.It is good, but I found Kira*Kira to be so much better.In terms of other aspects, that is. In terms of "group of heroines", it is pretty damn good in that part. Still, you'll have to play it for yourself, especially since fans of both games have their reasons.Also, yes, they are most certainly right about Eiji. For Eiji is love, Eiji is life. I would play it quite soon if every Overdrive game didn't look exactly the same. Plus, I'm taking a long break from VNs. Quote
Yuuko Posted October 22, 2015 Posted October 22, 2015 Love all the heroines in Hatsusaku except Nozomu. Fuck Nozomu  Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.