Pick my next VN

[VirginSmasher]

I need a new VN to play. Some of the things that have been suggested to me I have put into a poll for you guys to vote on. These include Gahkthun, Comyu, and Forest. Which one should I play and I'll play these 3 in the order of votes they get from highest to lowest.

[Timeless Wizard]

I'm currently reading Gahkthun, almost finished. It is really good and I'm really loving it. Will highly recommend it, an excellent Visual Novel.

[ホアー ビち]

there aint no poll

[VirginSmasher]

15 minutes ago, ロル ビち said:

there aint no poll

There you go. Put a poll there for everybody.

[Guest]

Clannad

[Soulless Watcher]

Out of those three, I have only read Comyu. So, I can't really measure it with the others in your list. However, I will say that I highly recommend Comyu.

[Dergonu]

No Sono hana title on the poll, 0/10.

(Play Gahkthun yah scrub! )

 

[ホアー ビち]

On 2/23/2016 at 8:19 PM, Arata said:

no Sono hana title on the poll, 0/10.

(Play Gahkthun yah scrub! )

 

ur confusing me, r u dergonu?

[Dergonu]

Just now, ロル ビち said:

ur confusing me, r u dergonu?

Yes I am. Made  a new account to do some editing on my signature etc, (also wanted to back on a new account cuz I love this site), and ended up posting here on the wrong account

Well, here I am! Love me!

[Fred the Barber]

@VirginSmasher, by the way, your VNDB link is toast.

I voted Gahkthun, but Comyu is excellent, too. Haven't played Forest yet, but just in case you haven't heard, I have heard that a guide is strongly recommended for it; you shouldn't need one for the other two, though.

[Dergonu]

1 hour ago, Arata said:

No Sono hana title on the poll, 0/10.

(Play Gahkthun yah scrub! )

 

Well.. Guess I'll just quote myself ...

[Arcadeotic]

I'd say forest is the most interesting, but I'm still going to root for Gahkthun

[DarkZedge]

Has to be Comyu, no other choice...i'm glad it's winning so far...GOOOOOO Comyu!

 

[DarkZedge]

9 hours ago, Dergonu said:

Well.. Guess I'll just quote myself ...

Quoteception by senpai 

[VirginSmasher]

There's a tie between Comyu and Gahkthun. Make your cases on which game I should play and why it's better than the other. Votes will still be accepted as well.

[ChaosRaven]

Comyu has a particular strong character cast with Kagome and Mayuki as heroines and a cool antagonist with Gasai. And the character interaction between the protagonist and the trio of Kagome, Benio and Mayuki in particular was great. I didn't play Gahkthun so I can't really judge its quality, but just from the comments I've seen, the only winable heroine doesn't exactly seem to be the greatest.

So if you want a great heroine cast I'm pretty sure you're better off with Comyu, if you're more into the mood for a good story, Gahkthun 'might' be the better choice since I wouldn't exactly say that the story was a strong point of Comyu.

[XReaper]

read forest, like seriously, this is modern art at its finest! no regrets - just go for it, damn it!

[Fred the Barber]

1 hour ago, ChaosRaven said:

Comyu has a particular strong character cast with Kagome and Mayuki as heroines and a cool antagonist with Gasai. And the character interaction between the protagonist and the trio of Kagome, Benio and Mayuki in particular was great. I didn't play Gahkthun so I can't really judge its quality, but just from the comments I've seen, the only winable heroine doesn't exactly seem to be the greatest.

Neon is actually one of my favorite VN heroines, so don't knock it until you try it.

They're both excellent VNs. Having played both of them, I will offer a simple suggestion: just play both of them, and maybe flip a coin or something to pick the first one