Yume Posted January 27, 2014 Posted January 27, 2014 https://forums.fuwanovel.net/index.php?/topic/3250-vnanime-recommendation-sub-forum/Since i didn't found any thread that help you to choose which VN that you want to play. So i make one. Because there'll be too many people who will make a new thread just want to have a suggestion "What VN should i play!?". If you are after an Visual Novel suggestion pop in a few things like:The genre of Visual Novel you want to play; in saying this it isn't a necessity but it makes it easier for people to offer suggestions.Give examples of similar Visual Novel you may have seen. If you have a Visual Novel Database (VNDB) account with a few titles of what you've seen already this comes to be a lot easier.A brief description of what kind of a Visual Novel you wish to play. With this out of the way we move on to the part of offering suggestions to particular users which is simpler if you do something that includes:Try to break up certain aspects of your suggestion list by grouping similar Visual Novels together or, if they're after multiple genre requests, group them into their respective labels.Some people prefer being able to organise their plan-to-watch lists by watching one genre type at a time.Possibly give your own short take on the Visual Novels titles which doesn't have to be much, even a few words is better than nothing at all.Take into consideration of which Visual Novel they've listed as already seen or the comparative title they're after.Offer a few Visual Novels titles at a time, even if they are the Fandisc of the same named Visual Novel title as most people might skip Fandisc since they didn't know about them.Here's an Example:Q : I want to play VN that could make me Cry like Clannad do! Can you give me some VNs that similar like that?A : You can play Little Buster! or Rewrite both came from same company but if you want to taste a different company you can try Hoshizora no Memoria. and many else! PS: You can suggest an untranslated VNs too.My Words : Helping each other is a good thing! (Common)
Alucard Posted January 27, 2014 Posted January 27, 2014 Vndb is a good resource for info on vn which may be a good place to start for some. Though the sheer amount of titles and tags can be a bit to sift through.
Flutterz Posted January 27, 2014 Posted January 27, 2014 I think the general consensus is that we either need a separate subforum for suggestions, or leave things the way they are. I'm not sure which one I'd prefer, but a single thread for it all doesn't seem like a very good solution to me. If multiple people ask for suggestions at roughly the same time it can get really confusing as to which posts refer to whom. SieghartXx 1
Alucard Posted January 27, 2014 Posted January 27, 2014 I think the general consensus is that we either need a separate subforum for suggestions, or leave things the way they are. I'm not sure which one I'd prefer, but a single thread for it all doesn't seem like a very good solution to me. If multiple people ask for suggestions at roughly the same time it can get really confusing as to which posts refer to whom. If you reply to a specific request you can just quote them
Flutterz Posted January 27, 2014 Posted January 27, 2014 By using "Quote" ? The quote on these forums is kind of weak, it only quotes the last post. And regardless, lots of people never use them. It'd be different if quoting all the time was common practice, but it's not.
SieghartXx Posted January 27, 2014 Posted January 27, 2014 I agree that one single thread would be really confusing, let's just wait for that subforum initiative (this). I would like a thread per user, although it could make things a bit messy.
O. Van Bruce Posted January 27, 2014 Posted January 27, 2014 Wouldn't it be best to actually assign a "recommender" to each genre? If there is a known user that has read lots of romance or mistery or moege or nukige, etc. titles, let him/her be the one recomending and so with a set of defined genres. That way, a more specialized approach can be given and people would be less confused when 3 or 4 people suggest different titles. Also, a single thread for each genre would be good. Just saying... because I started some VN after reading about then on VNDB and I dropped then due to not being what I expected.
SieghartXx Posted January 27, 2014 Posted January 27, 2014 Wouldn't it be best to actually assign a "recommender" to each genre? If there is a known user that has read lots of romance, mistery, moege nukige, etc. titles, let him/her be the one recomending and so with a set of defined genres. That way, a more specialized approach can be given and people would be less confused when 3 or 4 people suggest different titles. That's not a bad idea, like Clephas and Kaguya's recommendation topics :'D
Flutterz Posted January 27, 2014 Posted January 27, 2014 Wouldn't it be best to actually assign a "recommender" to each genre? If there is a known user that has read lots of romance, mistery, moege nukige, etc. titles, let him/her be the one recomending and so with a set of defined genres. That way, a more specialized approach can be given and people would be less confused when 3 or 4 people suggest different titles. Eh, that seems like something that splits the community, "this guy can recommend x, but this other guy only read 2 VNs in the genre and can't." Also several people who have read the exact same VNs can have drastically different opinions about them.
Yume Posted January 27, 2014 Author Posted January 27, 2014 I maybe should make another Example : Q : "Hey! i want a Visual novels that has good romance ,mystery and drama on it but please there's no rape at there!" A : You should play [Put your VNs Suggestion here]. since [Put Your Reasons here].
Yume Posted January 27, 2014 Author Posted January 27, 2014 Eh, that seems like something that splits the community, "this guy can recommend x, but this other guy only read 2 VNs in the genre and can't." Also several people who have read the exact same VNs can have drastically different opinions about them. It's all up to requester whether they want to take the suggestion or not.
Flutterz Posted January 27, 2014 Posted January 27, 2014 I maybe should make another Example : Q : "Hey! i want a Visual novels that has good romance ,mystery and drama on it but please there's no rape at there!" A : You should play [Put your VNs Suggestion here]. since [Put Your Reasons here]. That's pretty much what I already do.
O. Van Bruce Posted January 27, 2014 Posted January 27, 2014 Eh, that seems like something that splits the community, "this guy can recommend x, but this other guy only read 2 VNs in the genre and can't." Also several people who have read the exact same VNs can have drastically different opinions about them. It's true that there is a set of VNs that lots of people have read but when you have to deal with a complete newbie to the genre, the more specific the better... Also, I didn't say that only that person can recomend but it's good to know wether someone has more experience than other.
Alucard Posted January 29, 2014 Posted January 29, 2014 Now this takes me back but what are some more current games that would be similar to an old game called "season of Sakura" that people would like to recommend. Also has anything ever come out with an English translation that is close to the game true love?
Yume Posted January 31, 2014 Author Posted January 31, 2014 Now this takes me back but what are some more current games that would be similar to an old game called "season of Sakura" that people would like to recommend. Also has anything ever come out with an English translation that is close to the game true love? Never tried that VN. . . hmm.. Ikikoi is a good choice, since you will find a "True love" at there Xd
wattstax Posted February 1, 2014 Posted February 1, 2014 Don't know if it fits here, but I try it anyway Want to order some games over on mangagamer for download. I chose Kara no Shoujo and both ef-titles. Can you recommend them? They seem decent in art and plot. Does anyone know the games Loren The Amazon Princess and Jisei? Although no VN in the regular sense, they look interesting.
Yume Posted February 1, 2014 Author Posted February 1, 2014 Did you have ever tried DearDrops or Kira*Kira ? seems both translated from MangaGamer and had a decent graph , maybe you can give it a shot! Xd and, no never heard of those games. . ~
Recommended Posts