The Official Fuwa Anime Club: Voting and Summer Season Sign-Up

[Stray Cat]

Well, we've been going for a quarter now guys.  I must say I'm both shocked and thrilled that the club as been so popular.  Therefore, this seems like a perfect time to stop a bit and review and make sure we're going in the right direction.  I have posted a couple key questions in the poll above so it would be helpful if you could fill that out (NOTE anyone can fill it out if you have or have not participated at any point).  Additionally, if you have any comments, concerns, suggestions or the like, please PM either me or Nosebleed about them and we'll be happy to hear them.  

 

My goal here is to make this club something enjoyable for everyone, whether you're already an avid anime fan or just getting interested and want some people to talk with and help guide you along the way.  I realize I can't meet everyone's needs and sometimes these needs conflict but I'll try to do my best to find solutions that satisfy everyone and keep the club prosperous for a long time. 

 

Well, that's all I have to say.  Go enjoy some Milky Holmes. 

[kyrt]

I still think the various cycles (normal, seasonal, etc...) should each be in a separate thread; especially if we get other types of cycles.

 

Not really enjoying milky holmes...but I very rarely care for slapstick or comedy in general so that could be why.

[FinalChaos]

Okay so here's my super late review for Madoka Magica

I watched the series and then the third movie.

 

Story - 8/10

The story was good throughout, the movie seemed to fit properly with the series for me unlike what many others were saying. The premise was well done.

And God that gag in the movie where Mami has her code-name or something as cheese and Bebe keeps saying that she wants to eat cheese.

[Stray Cat]

I've finished season 1 and the Summer Special.  Its not even funny anymore per say but it's amusing so I'm enjoying it well enough.  Now on to season 2.

 

Also, reminder that anyone can fill out the survey poll. 

[Kat]

Wow. I thought it would at least make me laugh, but oh well. Just started 2nd season, hopefully it becomes better

[Nosebleed]

The secret to enjoying Milky Holmes is to expect absolutely nothing.

 

Expecting any kind of meaningfulness from Milky Holmes is already a step in the wrong direction.

[Shikomizue]

I've finished season 1 and the Summer Special.  Its not even funny anymore per say but it's amusing so I'm enjoying it well enough.  Now on to season 2.

 

Ugh, I'm procrastinating watching Milky Holmes. I'm still on episode 5.

[Stray Cat]

Wow. I thought it would at least make me laugh, but oh well. Just started 2nd season, hopefully it becomes better

[Kurisu-Chan]

Still hadn't watched milky holmes;

[FinalChaos]

Watched till ep 6 of Milky Holmes.

 

It is enjoyable and I don't get bored watching it, but beyond that it's hardly anything special.

Some of the scenes do make me laugh........ some

 

 

And yeah Arsene best girl.

[Stray Cat]

I'm halfway through season 2.  I feel like the more you watch the funnier it gets.

 

Reminder, one week left.

[Nosebleed]

Might as well post my review of milky holmes

 

Story: Banana/10

Characters: Fish Paste/10

Artstyle: Twenty's Nipples/10

Sound: Kokoro-chan is best idol/10

Overall: Lard/10

 

I could have written a long and thorough explanation but, just like Milky Holmes, it would be pointless.

[Kat]

Review for MH.

Story

9999999999999/10

Haha, NO!

Artisticery

8/10

Nipples. Arsene's boobs. Face Expressions

Music

?/10

I don't remember hearing anything. Guess that means it was not bad but not good to too.

Enjoyment

I just wanted to laugh watching a comedy anime. BuT comedy wise MH was 3/10. It had some stuff. But no.

Overall 5/10

W/E

[Stray Cat]

I feel like I'm the only one enjoying this.  

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ghVOYwsPbM

[Kat]

You're the chosen one.

[Shikomizue]

I haven't even finished it yet, but I can already give you my review for Milky Holmes. And I'm completely serious with these ratings.

 

Story: There's a story?/10

 

Characters: Can't tell if Arsene is the villain, or their mother./10

 

Art: Colors. Shiny. Nipples./10

 

Soundtrack: Um.../10

 

Enjoyment: The characters are too idiotic to figure out that Henrietta is Arsene./10

 

Overall: Why did you make me watch this?/10

[Eclipsed]

Based on all of these lovely reviews I'm not sure if I made the right call skipping this cycle or not

[Shikomizue]

Okay just finished MH, so here's a more serious review.

 

Story: 6/10

 

While the story wasn't really exciting, it still gave a goal for the characters to accomplish, and that's all it needs.

 

Characters: 6/10

 

The characters are too idiotic when it comes to serious situations, and that took away some of the enjoyment for me. Don't get me wrong, I like a loveable idiot character, but the fact that they can't be serious about something for more than, like, an hour feels stupid to me.

 

Art: 8/10

 

The art was actually quite nice, very colorful and lively

 

Soundtrack: 5/10

 

To be honest the music wasn't my style, and it felt like it was a background element.

 

Enjoyment:

Beginning: 4/10   Middle: 6/10   End 8/10  Though when they lost their toys AGAIN, my feeling of accomplishment was destroyed.

 

Overall: 7/10

 

While at first I didn't like it, eventually it grew on me. So I'll probably watch all of the seasons later.

[Stray Cat]

Based on all of these lovely reviews I'm not sure if I made the right call skipping this cycle or not

It honestly depends on your sense of humor and stuff.  I feel like if you enjoyed idiotic cartoons as a child this would be your thing. 

[Nosebleed]

There's idiotic funny and idiotic retarded

Idiotic funny is something like Nichijou or Daily Lives of Highschool Boys.

Idiotic retarded is something like Milky Holmes.

[FinalChaos]

Watched till ep9 and I have to say that grandpa Sherlock Holmes was pretty cool.

[Stray Cat]

There's idiotic funny and idiotic retarded

Idiotic funny is something like Nichijou or Daily Lives of Highschool Boys.

Idiotic retarded is something like Milky Holmes.

I would personally say Nichijou is more random humor than idiotic humor. 

[FinalChaos]

Just finished the first season of Milky Holmes.

 

Well I legitimately laughed a lot at how MH found out that Henriete=Arsene.

 

 

 

And apart from that Daily Lives of HighSchool is still the best comedy anime I've ever seen.

[Nosebleed]

The problem with milky holmes is that it expects you to laugh at brain dead characters. It's not random, there's no gags, It doesn't attempt to do anything with its characters, they just put 4 girls who can't do anything and then you have to find it funny.

Some people laugh, others are just left there scratching their heads, and that is essentially the problem Milky Holmes has and why some people think it's stupid and others find it funny.

[Stray Cat]

Yea, for me parts will not be funny and then it'll be insanely hilarious for a couple of minutes then not funny again, etc. etc. Considering how few things can make me actually laugh out loud though I give it props for being able to do it sometimes.