Nisekoi - The studio that helped animate the Monogatari series has made this anime soo gooooood looking. It's good looking animations + a pretty good rom-com just makes it a must watch. Lots of people have told me it's a very bland rom-com, but I'm enjoying quite a bit. Looking into reading the manga, but I know if I do that I'll begin lagging behind the anime like I always do.
Magi - I followed it during season one. I've been keeping up with the manga as well and I feel like it's going to end up as a giant series like Naruto/One Piece/Bleach. So since I'm riding with it already, might as well stay with it so I can finally say I've kept up with a giant series lol. For me it's not a high watch priority so I might lag behind every few weeks, but that's probably because I'm reading the manga and just seeing what I've already read.
Gurren Lagaan - I just find this gold mine. Loooove it soooooo much, I can't believe it's taken me so long to find this thing. No regrets. I'm kinda sad that I'm almost done with the series actually. Thank God I also have Kill la Kill. This writer needs to write more, I love his two animes, they're def some of my favorites of all time.
Kill La Kill - Obviously have to watch this. Not as good as Gurren Lagaan, but still a great anime, great art, and now it's just getting good. Not as many feels as Gurren, but I think in the recent and future episodes some feelings are being built
Blast Tempest - My back up anime, was suggested but not my style. It seems okay. But yea, just my back up anime to fall back on if I ever catch up to the anime I'm actively watching.