Thanks for the warm welcome and recommendations!
Yeah, Sonohana really hit a spot I enjoyed a lot. I'm not opposed to nukige games, but I really prefer the milder stuff, and yuri is definitely up there for my favorite genre. And I unfortunately cannot read Japanese. I haven't put any time into trying to learn yet.
I figured he was from the tags but I still would have played it for a laugh. Too bad the tumblr post with the download link was deleted.
I've played The Fruit of Grisaia, and started Labyrinth but dropped it... I liked most of the routes of the first one, but I was really disappointed by Amane's route... And Makina's Bad End will leave me scarred forever. I'm the type who likes to get all of the possible endings....
Majikoi looks intresting, I may pick that up sometime. I want to play Clannad but I think 50 bucks is maybe excessive for a VN as old as it is, And Little Busters is a better price, but I don't know much about it. I'm not sure of my interest in Propeller's work though.
Lots of interesting looking recommendations here. Seabed looks up my alley, definitely going to check that out. Same with Symphonic Rain. It has a rhythm game tag on VNDB and I do love rhythm games. I saw Nurse Love Addiction seconded, so I'll probably give it a play at some point.