you could do a hybrid of both allow members of the forum to reply under there name and have the anon box deal for those not interested in becoming a active participant in the community. i lurked for a long time before finally deciding that i wanted to see what the others who used the site were like, and now that i know many of the users here the opinions they have carry more weight for me than a anon message from a lurker . im sorry if a message in the box says "why even play this its a crappy game" from anon user, id be less likely to care then if one from clephas or kaguya or nosebleed stating" standard moege arts good, soundtracks poor id only play this once and then only if i didn't have others to read" the sense of community having a avatar and name with attached personality builds is much stronger to me than anon posts that could be from anyone who i have no reason to trust the opinion of. the members and staff here are some of the best ive ever found and iv been too dozens of forums for different topics . that quality of members is rare and should be showcased and when you consider alot of the reason people use the site is to get news on upcoming title translations and download torrents of available titles having people with experience can mean the world of difference for a newbie starting out. when i first started i played katawa shoujo and had to have more then i found fuwa and there were so many titles it was hard to know where to start and in some cases how to even get the titles to run in the first place.