I do have it (played and completed most of it), and I'll say that that idea is basically 50/50. BotW takes the open world idea and gives it some nice extra ideas, like more interaction with the environment and objects thx to Link's runes and physics. But the world is also a bit simplistic, the monsters very few in details and variety, and the game loses kind of their imagination after the 50/60th shrine. It really doesn't take the formula anywhere forward.
The thing is, BotW is a reaaaaally great game. But a really great game implies an 8, maybe. But scores are so very inflated, and mainstream franchises are always so hyped up, that the game got insta-10/10 everywhere even from people whose review basically admits that the game is faulty in some areas and aspects.
And I agree, but I think that it speaks of one of the ills that "we" have in the videogame world that we care so little for objectivity sometimes. And we are at a point that if a game gets less than a 7, it's considered a failure. We are at a point where videogame scores are starting to mean nothing, and annual prizes are delivered to whoever makes more noise, not quality.
I do not agree to the last part, though. I don't consider asinine to be critic of the culture of the overhype and score inflation that we have and see on most games. I don't consider myself superior for seeing P5 as the better game, but I do think that it's definitely more good than bad to dislike the current situation. I'm not about to lead a rebellion to change the world, but I do still think about this stuff.