Jump to content

DobUp

Members
  • Posts

    19
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by DobUp

  1. Really ? Apart from the Michiru's route, Yuuji isn't an asshole. Given his past and his actions in the present I don't think he's despicable. If there's one thing : I had a good impression of him during my playthrough.
  2. Michiru is quite good and very original. It's my least favorite character after Yumiko but I have to admit that she is well constructed through the dialogues. She's not over-utilized in the common route I don't understand why you're complaining. But everyone knows who the true tsundere is. What makes Grisaia's girls so awesome is the presence of our almighty Yuuji, simply one of the best VN's characters imo. Repartee ? Yes. Brain ? Yes. Japanese Solid Snake ? Yes. (Sachi is the best girl #wet )
  3. Is that so ? Arh, that wasn't clear to me. You saved my life here, I was ready to launch a New Game and re-do everything from the beginning using this slow "fast-forward". Thanks.
  4. Hi, I'm currently playing Steins;Gate and I'm following this walkthrough : http://ibm5100.net/steinswiki/2011/10/22/steinsgate-walkthrough-all-endings-100-cg-achievements/ I'm in chapter 6 and as you can see there are some choices like calling Mayuri or Luka and we can choose to make a call to a lab member later in this chapter, but I'm in the end of it and I had no choices at all. I loaded the game from an older save but I've the same problem. Why ? It's really pathetic to have this kind of bug in a visual novel where it isn't any gameplay, I can't understand. What can I do ? Thanks !
  5. 1. Rance as protagonist. 2. I don't care about the rest.
  6. I'm not against true routes, but I prefer VN that doesn't have one yeah, because a "true ending" is something imposed to the player, if there are heroines routes, it's a lot better to consider each of them as "what-if", thus the fanbase is always satisfied. (And a true route isn't always superior to the sides-routes)
  7. Given the fact there is Kotori,Lucia and Akane route, I don't really think this is pointless.
  8. I agree, it's all according to what people think is valuable but when a VN is appreciated, it's undoubtedly good in some way, that's the difference between high-ranked VN and the big jokes like "Maiden Rape Assault: Violent Semen Inferno". It's not a quality at all, but that doesn't mean the VN has to be skipped, there are people who see Muv-Luv as torture but MLA is interesting. (Yes, there are two distinct games but I can say the same thing for ML Extra=> Unlimited~) "it automatically rates highly, it doesn't matter how tedious the meat of the novel is." Perhaps you don't wanted to mean it like that but it sounds arrogant, like they are judging on crummy concepts.
  9. Damn. If you want to call a VN "shitty", then you need arguments. Not negative adjectives without example, you're just trying to be credible with a haughty tone "Of course, I know what I'm talking about, other peoples are just simple-minded peons, this VN is overrated without doubt". It's just detestable and I really can't think you can called any VN with 8+ rating an "average" VN, I disliked Ever17 a lot nevertheless, when you see it's convinced so many people it's really hard to impose the fact this VN is a piece of shit and there's nothing more dumb than attacking the fanbase to justify "my tastes are universal hue". I'm stating the obvious but it's not the case for everyone it seems.
  10. "In this world, there is no truth. The truth is made later on and overwrites what comes before it. Real truth doesn't exist anywhere." Beatrice, Umineko No Naku Koro Ni "A match won't be resolved unless enemies and allies gather." Bernkastel, Umineko No Naku Koro Ni "There is nothing that is not healed with TIME. And there is no truth that cannot be reached if you spend enough time SEARCHING" Dlanor A. Knox, Umineko No Naku Koro Ni "Promises are made to be broken" Virgilia, Umineko No Naku Koro Ni "Both love and happiness are the same as the air. Even though it fills the world, if you don't understand it, it's the same as if it doesn't exist." Lambdadelta, Umineko No Naku Koro Ni "Once you've gained credibility, your forgeries will rise to the level of truth." Ushiromiya Ange, Umineko No Naku Koro Ni "By learning things, people change the way they live, but not always in a good direction. There are plenty of things in this world that you'll be more comfortable not knowing" Furudo Erika, Umineko No Naku Koro Ni Yes, all quotes are from Umineko, I really like them.
  11. Freezing Lucia isn't their top priority, that was the priority of the Guardian's project at the time, but given the fact they wanted to use Lucia to clean Kazamatsuri if she didn't do it by herself, it's hard to believe they still want to send her into the future, they were ready to get rid of Lucia, so yeah, the Adam/Eve project was no longer relevant. Perhaps you misunderstood something because the antagonist was brainwashing Lucia about this "You're not useless anymore, you can give a future to the humanity, so destroy everything because only beings who means something will remain blahblah.." and it's really implied in a discussion with Nishikujou that Brenda (main antagonist) is just a mad terrorist manipulating Lucia for some irrealistic goal doesn't related to what she officially claim. Something like that.
  12. "half of the main plot" No, just take the scientists in an other way, they're here to awake Lucia's psychological problems, for the plot (who almost stand by itself with the Kotarou-Lucia relationship alone). Don't say you accorded importance to their objective ? It's typical of R07 writing style, I don't know if you have read Umineko and if yes I could give you few examples. Because it's the same thing here, you're complaining too much about the scientists objectives, it's just a means to reach the conclusion wanted by R07, it's not a question of "rose colored glasses" because there are readers who have took the story in the way wanted by the author. It's maybe not credible for you but in the route it's mentioned they were going to drop Lucia's cabine over Kazamatsuri to eradicate everything if she denied their proposal. At this point I can't really agree with you, they become a terrorist organization, not a group of dumbass searching for two people to cryogenized. Compared to the route's focus, yes the scientists are just a pretext, they lack of original objectives or charism but they're not incoherents and after all : it's trivial. :sakuya:
  13. Critics aren't objective, they're critics because they can (theoritically speaking huh) provide a good analysis of a movie, a book... normally they don't want to impose their point of view, just peel a story and its meaning. Lucia route is a good example, I said (and given an example of a little review) why you can't judge Lucia's route about something trivial (yes it is) like the scientists, they're just a pretext for Lucia's development. And I really don't think I'm someone who can be called a "rose colored glasses" wearer, sadly I'm really harsh about things like that and I'm trying to give a different gaze to stories, recently,but nobody care heh, I just like to justify myself. I insist, you can't pretend judge this route from an objective viewpoint (me neither maybe) , you don't like it as much as other ppl do, it's understandable and not really new, that's all. For your last paragraph, even if I don't really care about them (not a flaw nor a quality imo), I'm pratically sure it's mentioned, but I don't remember if it's in the first or latter half, I'll give it a glance and send you a screen if I'm not wrong.
  14. How can you say "objective angle" when talking about a story ? Or writing ? Especially when talking about this route. Damn I wanted to answer but that's actually just incredibly dumb. You complained about the Adam/Eve thing ( it said they're searching an Adam, hey). But never mind, be focused on the scientist story is like skipping the route, it's typical from Ryukishi's writing, the only people who think it's bad written are inflexible people, I don't want to extrapolate but it's a fact, that's the same thing for Umineko and Higurashi's haters who played the game just to find the culprit, it's more than that, don't be stuck on a mechanical view of a story, with this mentality a lot of books and VN have been wasted. I don't want to waste my time arguing about an "objective" view of a story (further, there isn't any incoherence, maybe it lacks of realism for you, but the story is coherent). The route is primarly about Kotarou and Lucia's relationship, I repeat myself but it's just so obvious... And I don't have the time at the moment so I drop this, it's a good review to show what I want to say : http://kakeracomplex.wordpress.com/2013/01/31/rewrite-lucia-route-reflection/ I don't intend to impose my opinion, merely the point of view necessary to really appreciate the story, it was written for this purpose.
  15. Ah, I somehow understand what is the problem , guess I can't really argue about this because our vision of the route is totally opposed. After all the horror atmosphere disappeared because the principal mystery is cleared and it's the same for the other phase shifts, that wasn't abrupt at all, the fact the route was versatile in many good ways, imo, really seduced me actually. And I didn't say Kotarou was comparable to any of the other route, he's just incomparable in this romance domain because that's the only route when he is in such a situation, from it,he was just foolish like many MC when it comes to love and I'm rather accustomed to it, I can't say that was a good point so.
  16. It's well written, I know I shouldn't talk about my personnal feelings when discussing about it but I'm REALLY allergic to anything who tend to be "moe" and Lucia's route just cured me, the date scene is very good in this point, that was the first time of my life I didn't puke facing this sort of romance. It's obvious that the antagonist is pretty useless, it was just a pretext and it's one of the route's failures yeah but what next ? There isn't any atmosphere problem at all, I mean the transition between each "phase" is fine, it's not like Lucia changed her mind at X moment just for the plot's sake, as has been stated many times, she was mentally weak, and I really will call this variety of atmosphere a strong point of this route. About the idiocy of Kotarou, he's dumb yeah but : is it not credible ? or incoherent ? At this point you just didn't like the story itself, Lucia's route is pretty much the only Rewrite's route romance centered and I didn't find the tactless Kotarou surprising given the other routes. Concerning the message, the route has one , rather cliché but in the end, all that really mattered was that Kotarou loved Lucia and what it was good isn't the message but the execution itself, I don't reproach many things. (And sorry for my english, I still have some problems it comes to write.)
  17. Yeah I planned to do so, Clannad seems good (i'm interested in AS) , it's already installed but I don't want to play too much VN at the same time because I'm already reading Grisaia.
  18. Well, Rewrite is just the best Key's VN imo, I read them all (except Clannad and Air) and damn, it's just so refreshing to have a VN made by Key who is actually interesting from the beginning to the end, not stuck to minor details and boring SoL during the whole game. And yes Kotarou is undeniably a very good protagonist, NOT a disgusting bland MC like a lot of VN (although Rance is the best hey) he has a strong personality as has been said and he's very well constructed during the VN (even if I didn't like Terra's Kotarou) . For the precedent discution, Lucia is the best route of Rewrite. I agree, her route is kinda disconnected from the rest but when you look at the route itself, who is totally mastered and well written (we're talking about Ryukishi ), it's very very solid, this route knew its objective and doesn't deviate from it, there was a good balance between the relationship with Lucia & Kotarou and the rest. The message is maybe simple and there is some failures but overall it's just phenomenal and the whole thing is deeply satisfying.
×
×
  • Create New...