Thoughts on Grisaia no Kajitsu [Spoilers]

[nohman]

I actually feel that running away serves best at the bad end, because ultimately the routes are about solving the heroines problems and in the bad end that wasn't the case. Other than being able to not be bothered by Michiaki it didn't solve any of Yumiko's problems internally. Also, if you think about it due to the influence of Ichigaya that confrontation wasn't that far-fetched.

 

I agree, I wasn't suggesting the good end was farfetched, unrealistic, or the worse of the two endings. I was commenting on how it made sense that running away was the bad end, though it hardly warrants that distinction.

 

EDIT: Oh, I think you were commenting on what edwd2 said. My mistake.

[madvanced]

I agree, I wasn't suggesting the good end was farfetched, unrealistic, or the worse of the two endings. I was commenting on how it made sense that running away was the bad end, though it hardly warrants that distinction.

I had more qualms about Michiru's choice rather than Yumiko's.

[nohman]

I had more qualms about Michiru's choice rather than Yumiko's.

 

Both Sachi and Michiru's choices were pretty bad tbh. Amane's, Yumiko's, and Makina's were more meaningful and had a clearer line of consequence.

[madvanced]

Both Sachi and Michiru's choices were pretty bad tbh. Amane's, Yumiko's, and Makina's were more meaningful and had a clearer line of consequence.

Sachi's wasn't that bad, yeah it wasn't ideal but it made some sense. Michiru's was completely devoid of cause and effect.

[nohman]

Sachi's wasn't that bad, yeah it wasn't ideal but it made some sense. Michiru's was completely devoid of cause and effect.

 

Sachi's was good in the sense that it gave her perspective on what to focus on in tackling her guilt, but it ultimately had nothing to do with Yuuji giving her the key or her getting soap opera'd. Michiru's is definitely worse though.

[madvanced]

Sachi's was good in the sense that it gave her perspective on what to focus on in tackling her guilt, but it ultimately had nothing to do with Yuuji giving her the key or her getting soap opera'd. Michiru's is definitely worse though.

I see Sachi's like this, when she chooses to kill herself she doesn't waste any time after that and Yuuji can't catch up to her in the hospital, although the occurrence of the traffic accident may be a little far-fetched, when she chooses to kill her mother she wastes a lot of time because she doesn't understand that she must kill her image of her mother not her mother in itself, that was enabling Yuuji to catch up  to her. I get my reasoning pushes it a little but I think of it in this way.

[nohman]

I see Sachi's like this, when she chooses to kill herself she doesn't waste any time after that and Yuuji can't catch up to her in the hospital, although the occurrence of the traffic accident may be a little far-fetched, when she chooses to kill her mother she wastes a lot of time because she doesn't understand that she must kill her image of her mother not her mother in itself, that was enabling Yuuji to catch up  to her. I get my reasoning pushes it a little but I think of it in this way.

 

Oh yeah, I get that. One choice puts her in the exact place in time to get hit by a car. It makes sense. That doesn't make it a good set of choices though. Neither choice has any meaningful connection to the conclusion or can be anticipated. It simply comes down to coincidence.

[madvanced]

Oh yeah, I get that. One choice puts her in the exact place in time to get hit by a car. It makes sense. That doesn't make it a good set of choices though. Neither choice has any meaningful connection to the conclusion or can be anticipated. It simply comes down to coincidence.

That's why I said that it's pushing it a bit. But overall the two major qualms I had with the game were Makina's "good" end and Michiru's choices, otherwise it was a great game.

[Totodile]

in all honesty Makina's ending completely destroyed any respect i had for her route. If possible get that one done first and forget about it. Get Michiru's out of your way second (that route is more over the place than Amane's driving) then just cruise along with the other 3 at your own pace. Still flipping shit that there isn't a Chizuru route though. 

[BookwormOtaku]

Tunafish Man is now a Transformer:

 

http://www.escapistmagazine.com/news/view/137153-Takara-Tomy-Announces-New-Line-of-Sushi-Transformers

 

That is all B)

[Mr Poltroon]

Reviving threads. Such a wonderful feeling. 

 

Here's a question. From playing all of the routes, you surely formed your own image and character for Yuuji.

Using what you believe to be his character, do you think he was 'out of character' in some routes?

 

I think he always was in character according to what I grasped from it, but others may think differently.

[havoc]

Reviving threads. Such a wonderful feeling. 

 

Here's a question. From playing all of the routes, you surely formed your own image and character for Yuuji.

Using what you believe to be his character, do you think he was 'out of character' in some routes?

 

I think he always was in character according to what I grasped from it, but others may think differently.

he was mostly in character in my opinion.

Except for chiruchiru's route.

[Mr Poltroon]

he was mostly in character in my opinion.

Except for chiruchiru's route.

And why is that? What made you think he was out of character?

[Ezeefreak]

Reviving threads. Such a wonderful feeling. 

 

Here's a question. From playing all of the routes, you surely formed your own image and character for Yuuji.

Using what you believe to be his character, do you think he was 'out of character' in some routes?

 

I think he always was in character according to what I grasped from it, but others may think differently.

 

Ah man... I thought the hype about that mediocre VN has finally cooled down... how disappointing

 

But back to your question... I did not like Yuuji for the whole VN , so I wouldn't say he was out of character. There are only some fragments when i thought he was a real human, but this was quickly wiped out with the next scene ...

 

Greetz

[Down]

Ah man... I thought the hype about that mediocre VN has finally cooled down... how disappointing

Comyu was supposed to replace it as the latest big release... But with the anime and whatnot and Comyu being slightly less tuned to most people's tastes (more chuuni I suppose)...

And the hype will go up again when Meikyuu will be release, people have that to hype. Koestl is busy on Gahkthun so in 2018 maybe

 

Here's a question. From playing all of the routes, you surely formed your own image and character for Yuuji.

Using what you believe to be his character, do you think he was 'out of character' in some routes?

Definitely. I felt it while playing the story, and having learned later the details of who wrote what it makes even more sense.

It's especially blatant in Michiru's route, where in the first half he's just some sort of blank slate without his usual strong personality. This also manifests itself by less frequent and less witty monologues. But I think it's also true to an extent for Sachi's route... And maybe a bit Yumiko's. In those routes it's more about what he does to help the girls that feels slightly off.

[Poltroon]

I've finished reading this the other day, and I really liked it. 

It was really funny and cute most of the time :3

I liked Yumiko's route the most, she's also my favorite charecter.