What is a "good" H-scene.

[Eclipsed]

1. Well I think most VNs fail at making the transition because the characters are usually all sweet innocent virgin girls who don't even know what the male genitalia looks like and when the sex happens and they're suddenly all into it it feels off, but to be honest I've just accepted this as typical hentai and don't care much about it anymore and I don't think there's any other way around it. Like you said, if it's eroi it's eroi.

Funny enough I've met a 19 year old girl who didn't know what the male genitalia looked like either, so I guess it is possible to find a super innocent girl in real life given the right circumstances, 2. and yes I am using past tense for this, and no I wasn't the one who changed the situation.

[julyan]

As long the CG and acting is good (and of the course the girl is cute) it's already a winner for me.

I rarely read every line in an H-scene.

[suikashoujo]

Honestly, unless 1. it's a character I really like, or 2. the scene is particularly attractive for whatever reason, I don't usually read the H-scenes unless I'm in the mood for them. In story-based VNs, they tend to break the flow of the story in most cases, so I don't always read them (unless I'm visiting the scene selection gallery after I unlock the scene, in which case it has my full attention   ). Even when I do read them while reading the VN, I rarely read the whole scene, and tend to skip the text if the writing isn't very good.

 

That said, if it's a nukige, then it would weird not to read the H-scenes (although I skip the ones with fetishes I don't really care for). Of course I read those.

[OriginalRen]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jdwpkM-6SFU

 

I am sorry, it had to be done.

[Tyrael]

I need a H-scene to portray the woman in a way that's not totally degrading... Which seems to be a lot to ask since this is something most eroges fail to do in my experience. Unless of course it's a rape scene but those scenes are usually not made for the crowd to 'enjoy' them...

 

I also prefer scenes with characters that love each other 

[TexasDice]

A good H-scene can't be too hard to get into and I also prefer not to be cuntinuously reminded about the noises.  

[Avil]

H-scenes for the sake of porn are usually boring except when it reveals a new side of a character (ex: a shrinking violet being dominant) or makes you think "They are really in love" are ok.

And nukige scenes need to be exciting and dirty or there won't be different from a normal vn.

[mitchhamilton]

Anal.

[HMN]

a good H-scene should have yumiko or jinpou in it,obviously. 

[hsmsful]

a good H-scene should have yumiko or jinpou in it,obviously. 

[HMN]

You fucking noob, it needs a rin or sachi. Go somewhere else with your noobishness. 

[hsmsful]

hsms pls.

neither rin nor sachi have boobs. 

i rest my case.

[Darklord Rooke]

In my opinion, it's a scene which helps move forward the plot in some way, not just an excuse for porn. Of course, this only applies to story-focused stuff.

 

 

Agreed. To get to the purpose of a good h-scene, just figure out what the purpose of a scene is then just apply to a scene involving sex.

[XReaper]

not sure if i should honestly answer this

edit: its MOSTLY sufficient for me if there´s a good amount of peropero chupachupa included & please a seiju who DOENST sound like a horse on crack, as thats a huuuuge turnoff for me (sadly it happens in every 3rd vn though)

[Narcosis]

The vast majority of eroge has badly written sex scenes anyway and it happens for a reason. There's just a bunch of titles, that managed to pull off erotic content in a different way, remaining aesthetically encouraging whilst retaining it's function to please the readers; even then, little can be considered someting more than shallow entertainment and the line between sacrum and profanum is incredibly thin.

[B0X0R]

H-scene is good for me if it has CG that looks good and it's not like this:

"Hey I like you <3"

"I like you too<3"

"Wanna fuck?"

"Oh sure!"

[Parallel Pain]

I used to think just good sex, both showing each other love and enjoying themselves, and not too drawn out are good.

 

Well I still think that.

 

But H-scenes for Haruka and Kanata in LBEX stood out for me as going above and beyond that by showing another psychological of the participants (no not just showing love)

 

So that's now my criteria for a terrific and fantastic H-scene.

[Chewy]

Good art, nice voice acting and actual realistic art and voice acting, probably a little dose that makes it unique and wallah a good H scene... something like that

[Nyanko]

I might be a bit picky but; I prefer the h-scene in a VN to mean something special, the visualisation of the romance between the main character and the heroine. It would be optimal if there was only 1 special scene per heroine, or multiple with a decent amount of story in between, just to keep them special. My optimal H-scene would be with either no voices or everything voiced (main character included). The transition between normal conversation and a h-scene should be smooth. I also agree that they shouldn't be talking too much, and imo they shouldn't be writing out all those "uh.. ahh.. ughh... ohh" if it's voiced.

[Alucard]

Lots of cg and not just small variations on one image. I don't care for lots of stupid sound effects and loud moans. It would be nice if the writing was good but this is rare

[HMN]

Who cares about bewbs? u oppai newb

you clearly don't know the glory of paizuri.

[hsmsful]

you clearly don't know the glory of paizuri.

Hmph

who needs paizuri when there's the delicate touch of the hands of a cute girl .. and her mouth 

[Yuuko]

you clearly don't know the glory of paizuri.

You don't understand the justice of flat chest

[Kanbe]

I would say h-scenes that are really impactful to the story or relationship with the heroine. Other then that if it's worthy fap material for you, then I guess that's considered good too?

 

...also I prefer kyonyuus over flatties (forgive me kanasuke...)

[bogdankl]

can any1 give me a translated vn with some bad h scenes?

 

there's only 2 instances of h scene skipping i did

 

1. the first time i stumbled across one and that was when i played katawa <my first vn, hanako route> for some reason, even tho i knew it was in there and was waiting for it, i don't know why but when they started fking i was just like... 'this does not feel the way i was expecting it' <much guilt was felt that day>, i kinda really loved hanako and when i got at the end that scene turned 10x more bitter

2. nekopara, jesus fking christ was that bad, the whole "she's in heat" and "i'm only doing it cuz i'm worried" thing really stepped on my nerves for some reason and i didn't wanna see it <even tho the art and animation were pretty good i think>, also i might have something against cat-girls <maybe it's cuz i am a cat person>

 

so in short, bad writing, after all you are usually playing a vn for a while before you stumble across a h scene so you get kinda attached to a character, imagine if in g senjo no maou

kyouske actually raped usami when she came to him, or think about the bad ending of mizuha didn't read it but i did get the cg and it kinda shook me