Alright, I talked about heroines already, so now to the routes- I'll say the best was Suzu, which was really good, and second goes to Tanya, which got kinda close to it. Third was Touko and fourth was Kaoru.
Touko's route was really good, but Touko ruined it for me. I just don't like her type of heroine, and I disliked all the getting closer to her- she's cool in battle scenes, but that's about that. I reaally liked Hounan (is that her name? I'm really bad with names) Anyway, it's . And I would love to see a corruption-like ending.
Kaoru.... I really liked Suzu in that route! In fact, the way she tried to deal with Kaoru was what ended up giving her a spot in my favorite heroines corner. Pretty good route, another heroine that I disliked.
Tanya was great. She was a pretty good heroine and had a pretty good route. It was very solid, with lots of awesome and very few flaws. It's one of those routes that I liked so much it's hard to find a flaw to talk about.
Suzu was amazing. She's one of those characters that get worse with character development- She was 1ยบ place heroine material at the beginning of the game (and she's fighting with about 1000-something other heroines I know for that position, though she only rates that highly because she hit almost all of my sweetspots and none of my pet-peeves), not so much at the end, but still deserves a good place. Her route was the main dish of the game, and I realy loved all of the endings.
Overall, a great VN. Would get into the top 10 in the translated VNs list. And the fact that I disliked two heroines but still consider it to be that high shows it's quality.
Even the VNs considered top tier in the tld scene have some big flaws- Fate? All the boring exposition you get at the beginning of the fate route. Rewrite? Just look at that common route! Little busters? I had to held myself from skipping half of almost all heroine routes. The list keeps going- Even while disliking half of it's heroines, this game was really good. I couldn't find any big flaw like that, so there you have it.