No One But You Review Discussion

[Tyrael]

 

More terrible OELVN's, yay! I even had high hopes for this one too...

So, I was trying to wait for Unwonted Studios to release the 18+ patch but since that is apparently taking forever I decided to publish it anyways. I highly doubt it will do much to improve the overall quality of this hot mess anyways... 

 

Link: http://reviews.fuwanovel.net/2016/02/14/no-one-but-you-2/

[Valmore]

Wait, so you read my spoilery blog while still playing?

[Okarin]

Come on, they did Written in the sky. Ded studio.

[Tyrael]

29 minutes ago, Valmore said:

Wait, so you read my spoilery blog while still playing?

I believe I had already read three routes at that point (including Megumi's) so there was no harm done

[Diamon]

Was it the same team of writers who made Written in the sky though?

[DarkZedge]

I still haven't read this one and was going to soon because i had hopes...is it not good? not even a lil bit?

[Valmore]

56 minutes ago, DarkZedge said:

I still haven't read this one and was going to soon because i had hopes...is it not good? not even a lil bit?

Well, we've had two official non-spoilery FUWA reviews of it (Decay wrote one as well) and the average score between the two is 2.5, which means Tyrael was slightly more forgiving in his score. If you want spoilers to the route that agitated me the most and the one I was forgiving to (I actually liked the true route character well enough, even though the protagonist sucks), I have a couple blog posts - they do have major spoilers though, such as it is. If I were to write an actual review, it would pretty much be along the lines of the two writers before. It's... it's not good. The sprites and CGs are decent and you may be able to tolerate a route or two, but repeated readings into the other routes is just frustrating, but there's very little to call good in it.

[DarkZedge]

Just now, Valmore said:

Well, we've had two official non-spoilery FUWA reviews of it (Decay wrote one as well) and the average score between the two is 2.5, which means Tyrael was slightly more forgiving in his score. If you want spoilers to the route that agitated me the most and the one I was forgiving to (I actually liked the true route character well enough, even though the protagonist sucks), I have a couple blog posts - they do have major spoilers though, such as it is. If I were to write an actual review, it would pretty much be along the lines of the two writers before. It's... it's not good. The sprites and CGs are decent and you may be able to tolerate a route or two, but repeated readings into the other routes is just frustrating, but there's very little to call good in it.

Aw such a shame I had really high hopes for it and it looked pretty good....was expecting it to be at least decent

[CeruleanGamer]

I did it! I read @Tyrael's review. He won't be mad at me now. Great review btw.

[Tyrael]

3 hours ago, CeruleanGamer said:

I did it! I read @Tyrael's review. He won't be mad at me now. Great review btw.

Spoiler

 

[Deep Blue]

I like the novel 

[Tyrael]

10 hours ago, Deep Blue said:

I like the novel 

Are you interested in writing about it?

[Deep Blue]

25 minutes ago, Tyrael said:

Are you interested in writing about it?

I was waiting for the +18 patch, by the end of this week I will try to have a very bad review ready (I'm studying for exams that I have next week so I need some time to write something bad or at least "decent enough" xD)