I have created a top 40 favorite Visual Novel H-scene tier list. Enjoy.

[NowItsAngeTime]

 

 

So as said in the title, this list is more of a reflection of my top 40 favorite H-scenes cuz there's no way in hell I'm ranking all 300+ H scenes I've likely seen at this point in one list.

If you want to know all the characters/visual novels on this list:

Top Row to Bottom Row, Left to Right

* Ageha from Konosora/If My Heart Had Wings - https://vndb.org/c9334 , Yukie from MajiKoiS - https://vndb.org/c3511 
* Yorihime from Magical Marriage Lunatics - https://vndb.org/c14902, Mizuha from G-senjou - https://vndb.org/c400, Ritsuko from Princess Evangile W Happiness - https://vndb.org/c3105, Komomo from Hoshizora no Memoria - https://vndb.org/c3932
* Sakura from Fate/Stay Night - https://vndb.org/c35, Rio from Dracu-Riot - https://vndb.org/c5027, Asuho from Hoshizora no Memoria - https://vndb.org/c3910, Ema from Fashioning Little Miss Lonesome - https://vndb.org/c43353, Haruko from Haruko Maniax - https://vndb.org/c172, Touka from Sharin no Kuni - https://vndb.org/c506, Benio from Comyu - https://vndb.org/c1587
* Sawatari from Fureraba - https://vndb.org/c16558
* Hibari from Swan Song - https://vndb.org/c3992, Rina from Fureraba - https://vndb.org/c16555, Kanon from G-senjou - https://vndb.org/c399, Mizuki from Edelweiss - https://vndb.org/c339, Himeno from Da Capo III - https://vndb.org/c5312, Hibiki from Maitetsu - https://vndb.org/c39200
* Kei from Dies Irae - https://vndb.org/c28991, Nekoko from Yume Miru Kusuri - https://vndb.org/c1632, Riho from Deardrops - https://vndb.org/c5243, Chizuru from Labyrinth of Grisaia - https://vndb.org/c578
* Ruriko from Princess Evangile W Happiness - https://vndb.org/c3109
* Natsumi from Sharin no Kuni fandisc - https://vndb.org/c506, Muana from Sharin no Kuni fandisc - https://vndb.org/c15692, Elina from Dracu-Riot - https://vndb.org/c5028
* Kotori from Konosora/If My Heart Had Wings - https://vndb.org/c9333
* Ayumi from Kotori Love Ex P - https://vndb.org/c7545, Benkei from MajiKoi A-1 - https://vndb.org/c5868, Tomoyo from Tomoyo After - https://vndb.org/c45746, Ririko from Sharin no Kuni fandisc - https://vndb.org/c1375, Sachi from Fruit of Grisaia - https://vndb.org/c576, Renna from Tsujidou-san no Junai Road - https://vndb.org/c5399
* Umi from Koirizo - https://vndb.org/c14219
* Rise from Princess Evangile - https://vndb.org/c3104, Ayumi from Kotori Love Ex P - https://vndb.org/c7545, Yayoi from Deardrops - https://vndb.org/c5242, Ami from MajiKoi S - https://vndb.org/c9798

You may have noticed this tier list style is slightly different from the S through F that most people use. If you want this style, go to this site - http://www.mmcafe.com/tiermaker/dbfz/index_customize.html.

This'll probably the last time I post a public EOP tier list like this since the VNs are comin in slower. 

This month, I plan on starting on learning Japanese. So don't be surprised if a JOP tier list comes eventually, but not for a while.

Edited September 4, 2018 by NowItsAngeTime

[Thyndd]

So meat pot yes, defenseless anus nah huh 

Good work, focusing on the important aspects of life. I approve.

[MaggieROBOT]

A h-scene topic being created on my birthday??? You guys know how to bring me back!  

To keep the conversation going, I'm gonna share my top as well, since this list have a dangerously low amount of gay in it. I'm just gonna list them because paint is hard man. In no particular order.

• Scenes that were good because they were damn hot:

1. Michael x Neil (in this order) from Shingakkou (ofc): shorter guy tops taller guy, yes please.
2. The only consensual scene (rip) with Azusa from Omerta: after so many troubles, abuse and violence they went through, this was so sweet and satisfying. 
3. Tbh, the last scenes with Kiryu, Luka and Tachibana from Omerta because damn, this was one sexy game: the participants were really into it.
4. The second Gii x Ati scene from Sekien no Inganock: WHAT, A HETEROSEXUAL PAIRING, MAGGIE this was the most romantic scene I have read, it was simply beatiful.
5. The consensual scene between Keisuke and Akira from Togainu no Chi: I don't remember the text and the CG was only okay, but holy damn shit that voice acting was S+++!

• Scenes that were good because its writing was a masterpiece:

1. Shirou x Rin? from Fate/Stay Night: DEFENSELESS ANUS OF THIS HEROINE THAT FEELS LIKE A DOG FTW Although I think I lmao a lot on any of Sakura's scenes too, but can't remember them too well.
2. Matt x Maki wanting to fuck in Maki Fes!: I can't even begin to describe the poetry of the text of this scene.

[Kirashi]

I remember someone doing a topic like this with a huge work on h scene (which one were good or not) on a google doc. It was posted around one year ago if I remember right. Now that I think about it, someone has a clue about the name of this topic?

[NowItsAngeTime]

9 minutes ago, Kirashi said:

I remember someone doing a topic like this with a huge work on h scene (which one were good or not) on a google doc. It was posted around one year ago if I remember right. Now that I think about it, someone has a clue about the name of this topic?

That was me.

So this list is essentially a more up to date version of that google doc

[NowItsAngeTime]

24 minutes ago, MaggieROBOT said:

A h-scene topic being created on my birthday??? You guys know how to bring me back!  

To keep the conversation going, I'm gonna share my top as well, since this list have a dangerously low amount of gay in it. I'm just gonna list them because paint is hard man. In no particular order.

• Scenes that were good because they were damn hot:

1. Michael x Neil (in this order) from Shingakkou (ofc): shorter guy tops taller guy, yes please.
2. The only consensual scene (rip) with Azusa from Omerta: after so many troubles, abuse and violence they went through, this was so sweet and satisfying. 
3. Tbh, the last scenes with Kiryu, Luka and Tachibana from Omerta because damn, this was one sexy game: the participants were really into it.
4. The second Gii x Ati scene from Sekien no Inganock: WHAT, A HETEROSEXUAL PAIRING, MAGGIE this was the most romantic scene I have read, it was simply beatiful.
5. The consensual scene between Keisuke and Akira from Togainu no Chi: I don't remember the text and the CG was only okay, but holy damn shit that voice acting was S+++!

• Scenes that were good because its writing was a masterpiece:

1. Shirou x Rin? from Fate/Stay Night: DEFENSELESS ANUS OF THIS HEROINE THAT FEELS LIKE A DOG FTW Although I think I lmao a lot on any of Sakura's scenes too, but can't remember them too well.
2. Matt x Maki wanting to fuck in Maki Fes!: I can't even begin to describe the poetry of the text of this scene.

Happy bday

Im glad it got you happy to share your own favorites

[Ranzo]

I second that Gii x Atti scene it was absolutely beautiful, romantic and not only that, well written.

 

[littleshogun]

That's quite a dedication I must say, so good job there. Also I would like to admit that usually I skipped the H scenes, mostly because you can review it at the extra menu lol.

[Ichigo]

Why did you value this time presentation and writing instead of personal "fappability"? Have your criteria changed over time?

[NowItsAngeTime]

5 hours ago, Ichigo said:

Why did you value this time presentation and writing instead of personal "fappability"? Have your criteria changed over time?

Both are important to overall fappability

Writing doesnt necessarily relate to like how romantic/development heavy it is

Just how hot it was written and how long it was, etc

[Azgn]

Am I considered a deprived human being if I recognized almost all of them from the pictures alone.

 

[NowItsAngeTime]

2 hours ago, Azgn said:

Am I considered a deprived human being if I recognized almost all of them from the pictures alone.

 

Youre a fellow comrade in my eyes at least

[LanThief(HUN)]

20 hours ago, littleshogun said:

That's quite a dedication I must say, so good job there. Also I would like to admit that usually I skipped the H scenes, mostly because you can review it at the extra menu lol.

I won't argue whit that

[bakauchuujin]

Personally I think the Nekopara sex scenes are really great.

[LanThief(HUN)]

10 hours ago, bakauchuujin said:

Personally I think the Nekopara sex scenes are really great.

Yes indeed i have all vol of Nekopara and finishd it twice

Edited September 6, 2018 by LanThief(HUN)