Sanoba Witch or KoiKuma

[Wildbreed]

I bought  1 - many games this month and can only afford to buy one of these on release date. I am More inclined towards the former since Nekonyan is the publisher and Its a Yuzusoft title..

 

KoiKuma gives me Magical Marriage lunatics vibes and that one dint sit that well with me so there is also that

Edited October 14, 2018 by Wildbreed

[YomiPlays]

I like the games of Yuzusoft. So Sanoba Witch wins my vote.

[ShinRaikdou]

Sanoba Witch of course. Yuzusoft games is always worth buying.

KoiKuma is another unfinished vn without fandisc. Also it is Sekai, who knows how translation turns out.

[DSKS]

Definitely Sanoba. First of all it's a game from Yuzusoft, developer of games like Noble Works and Dracu Riot. Also, Nekonyansoft showed pretty good level of translation when they released Fureraba.

Edited October 14, 2018 by DSKS

[Mr Poltroon]

What I've seen of Ditzy Demons has seemed pretty good, but if your choice is either one or the other, Sabbath is a full length title whereas Ditzy Demons is more of a nukige.

[Wildbreed]

1 minute ago, Mr Poltroon said:

What I've seen of Ditzy Demons has seemed pretty good, but if your choice is either one or the other, Sabbath is a full length title whereas Ditzy Demons is more of a nukige.

Yea unfortunately i can only buy one of these on release.. i have spent too much money getting AC OD GOLD and RDR2 SE

[littleshogun]

Sounds like a difficult choice seeing that both of those were pretty much a moege, except not really. Especially when we knew that Nekonyan did have mouth watering announcements and still the new company, while Sekai is already established a number of fortune and yet the releases along with the announcements were pretty much quite less than desired (Most of those) not to mention the controversy that was surrounding them. So yeah rather than give the money to Sekai you better use the money to help Nekonyan there, and with that we could get to see more of them in the future.

PS - As for the VNs in question Sanoba did have some character development, while apparently Bokukotsu only did have some moe element. So I would say that just go for Sanoba there.

Edited October 14, 2018 by littleshogun

[Ren'ai Arrow]

Sanoba Witch

[namiultedjapanXD]

How is this even a debate? Koikuma has an egyptian catgirl heroine. Thats one of the best things I have ever see. Trust me, you will get your money's worth from Koikuma

 

 

10/10 fap material.

[Decay]

My unbiased opinion is that KoiKuma has fantastic fap material, but Sanoba Witch's isn't half bad either. If you want anything else from the game, then get Sanoba because KoiKuma is literally just a nukige whereas Sanoba is a full-fledged moege.

My biased opinion is Sanoba Witch 10,000%. Buy copies for all your friends too.

[Fred the Barber]

I'll be buying both on release, but I'll probably be playing KoiKuma first, for the same lone reason that other people have cited why you might pick it. Assuming your decision is motivated by literally anything beyond fap material, among these two, you're probably better off with Sanoba.

Also, RIP LocaLove.

[ShinRaikdou]

1 hour ago, namiultedjapanXD said:

egyptian catgirl heroin

Who is that? Only egyptian in there are mummy girl, and only catgirl is tiger wich is side heroine (she has route in fandisc).

[namiultedjapanXD]

Just now, ShinRaikdou said:

Who is that? Only egyptian in there are mummy girl, and only catgirl is tiger wich is side heroine (she has route in fandisc).

Oops forgot she wasn't a catgirl. The dark skinned one. 10/10

[ShinRaikdou]

9 minutes ago, namiultedjapanXD said:

Oops forgot she wasn't a catgirl. The dark skinned one. 10/10

I see. Well, dark skinned are indeed rare so you can count this as major pros.

Although Sanoba Witch has Meguru, who is funny and cute af, and also a gamer that plays on 3DS. Did I mention she is lonely and need your love? (NSFW wallpaper with her).

Edited October 14, 2018 by ShinRaikdou

[Wildbreed]

Yea i want something light to read by light i mean something relaxing with few laughs here and there.... Definitely Not a nukige..I mean i will be reading inbeween gaming sessions in order to relax  when i get back home from work..again in order to relax..

I usually read Nukige only when i feel like it..Plus from my impression of Sanoba Witch it has its fair share of sex scenes...5 per heroine if i am not wrong.. 

[adamstan]

19 minutes ago, Wildbreed said:

5 per heroine if i am not wrong..

Well, that's a lot. I wonder how all-ages edition compares in such case Considering how the story starts based on the description, it looks little pointless to make one for this VN

 

Edited October 14, 2018 by adamstan

[namiultedjapanXD]

25 minutes ago, ShinRaikdou said:

I see. Well, dark skinned are indeed rare so you can count this as major pros.

Although Sanoba Witch has Meguru, who is funny and cute af, and also a gamer that plays on 3DS. Did I mention she is lonely and need your love? (NSFW wallpaper with her).

I love the lightish dark skin color like that. Shame its rare

I just randomly got the desire to read sanoba. I'm not sure why . . .

Edited October 14, 2018 by namiultedjapanXD

[Wildbreed]

57 minutes ago, adamstan said:

Well, that's a lot. I wonder how all-ages edition compares in such case Considering how the story starts based on the description, it looks little pointless to make one for this VN

 

 

Taken from vnmusings review of Sanoba Witch 

Spoiler

H content: I don’t normally talk about H content for various reasons, but there are a few games where I think it deserves to be brought up in and this just so happens to be one of them. Normally, a game with a setting like this would probably end up as a nukige with just a ton of H spammed in as fap material; but Yuzusoft has actually found a way to legitimately make H a part of the story, and the majority of the scenes actually provide quite a bit to the way the story plays out. Granted, there’s still a lot of H (Nene has 9 H scenes) but the vast majority of them carry a pretty big meaning rather than just being porn. It feels really awkward to be recommending a VN based on its H content, but I believe this is one of the cases where it was done well and actually makes the game significantly better.

Spoiler

Nene has 9 H scenes Wow.. so Sanoba Witch just slightly falls short of a Nukige.. but not by much 

 

Edited October 14, 2018 by Wildbreed

[Fred the Barber]

TBH, I don't find the "nukige" and "moege" distinctions very useful nowadays... moege all seem to have so many H scenes that the distinction is kind of lost on me, unless it's purely one of attitude towards sex, rather than sheer quantity/density of sex.

[Incynerate]

19 hours ago, ShinRaikdou said:

Sanoba Witch of course. Yuzusoft games is always worth buying.

KoiKuma is another unfinished vn without fandisc. Also it is Sekai, who knows how translation turns out.

Unfinished? How so? (Genuine question, I know next to nothing about this VN)

[ShinRaikdou]

4 hours ago, Incynerate said:

Unfinished? How so? (Genuine question, I know next to nothing about this VN)

Obviously because of fandisc wich is has continuation as after stories (+ harem route, marriage endings) with main cast and you'll never see them translated. At least Sekai never tl any fandisc's out of kickstarter.

Edited October 15, 2018 by ShinRaikdou

[Incynerate]

6 hours ago, ShinRaikdou said:

Obviously because of fandisc wich is has continuation as after stories (+ harem route, marriage endings) with main cast and you'll never see them translated. At least Sekai never tl any fandisc's out of kickstarter.

I see. I thought maybe there was an issue with the base game itself, like a jarring ending that comes out of nowhere. I would also reccomend Sanoba, but I personally can live with having a supplementary mini-sequel not being translated.

[Wildbreed]

On 10/15/2018 at 6:28 PM, Incynerate said:

I see. I thought maybe there was an issue with the base game itself, like a jarring ending that comes out of nowhere. I would also reccomend Sanoba, but I personally can live with having a supplementary mini-sequel not being translated.

mini-sequel?

On VNDB i am seeing that the sequel is of 10-30 hours of length which is the same time frame as that of the base game..