A tabulation of feedback + my responses:
Member of the Month
“Though I think it would be nice to have special exceptions in the month if a user were to do something especially over the top and helpful.” – Stanleys (TAY: What do you mean by this?)
“it could work by some kind of voting system.” – maefdomn
A lot of people are creeped out by the wording of the MotM box and suggested it be replaced by my note in the “N” box. I’m not able to modify the text at the moment, sorry!
I’m not sure where would be best to put the MotM stuff. I could move it around on the index sidebar every few days so we can see what it looks like/find a position we like. During the start of the month (first day or two when the new MotM is announced) I think I’ll even make it a banner.
Facebook Bar
“I don't personnaly like the facebook feature, because it doesn't blend with the website well (blue<>green) and it doesn't feel necessary.” – maefdomn
A lot of people echoed that sentiment. I’ll try and see what I can do about it, but I doubt there’s much I can fix. I thought having a FB link on the forums index would be a good way to bolster our FB activity. I’d appreciate more feedback.
AWARDS
Proposed Ideas:
· Tournaments
· Competitions
· Giveaway winners/participants
· Those featured in blog user spotlight.
· People that contributed to Visual Novel Aer
· People with their own blog (see limitations below)
· Translators
· People who are participating in certain projects, like the Fuwanovel creations, Solidbatman's VN project, or Kanpachi's dubbing project
· Osu! players, or players of any other popular game or MMO (see limitations below)
· I also liked the idea about the Fuwapocalypse survivors (see limitations below)
· Member of the Month
· Awards for # of Awards (“"Awardception" - Collect 5/10/20 awards” )
· Tech support badges (I agree! But I’m not sure how to do this one)
· Maybe VN master for those who posted enough on the VN Talk forum, Anime Library for the anime/manga forum and Fuwa Tech for the fuwanovel improvements and tech support forums. (see limitations below)
· Facebook like fan (Tay: see limitations below)
· @fuwanovel Twitter follower (TAY: We’ve lost access to that twitter, but that aside, see limitations below)
· PSP/Handheld/Console VN Gamer, PC VN Gamer, Mobile VN Gamer (see limitations below)
· FuwanViewer user (Tay: see limitations below, but I want to make that happen )
· "Senpai noticed me!"
· "First post" or "First topic". (see limitations below, but a great idea)
· "Greet x newcomers" (see limitations below, bug another great idea)
USEFUL COMMENTS
“I feel like it would be really hard for new members to get. I see it as something encouraging people to ge involved, but people new to VN or new to the forums wouldn't really get anything out of it. It only rewards older members. So maybe make it more progressive so people can climb up the ladder one step after another.” – maefdomn (TAY: Good point. My response is that I haven’t come up with very many achievements yet. Just walkthroughs (which anybody can do) and post count (member rankings award up to 300 posts, and then there are awards for 500, 1500, 2000.) (I think we need to brainstorm awards which, like you say, will encourage new members)
“The award images don't go well with the website, maybe we could redesign them so tyey fit the theme more.” – maefdomn (TAY: Yup. That was me. I’m looking to all the talented graphics folks for help, here! : ))
“the button in the user info field is too big, the "User's Awards", its too fat, maybe it can be just text or at least as small as the buttons on the bottom of the posts.” – Steve (TAY: I agree. Working on it.)
Zhurai – being a rock is a good thing. Wear it with pride!
“I think it's not necessary to show +500/1000/1500/2000 post at the same time.”- maefdomn (TAY: As I’ll mention below, I have no ability ATM to allow users to choose which trophies to display. Right now it’s just a stream of the last 6 awarded)
“could show them off in their signatures.” - Yukiru (TAY: I actually have built-in functions for that! I just need to figure out how they work, and then I’ll share the info)
“Another thing is the "See award description" when you click a user's awards. Considering the box itself IS the description i see no need to have it there. One of them is already gone.” – Nosebleed (TAY: That’s my fault for reasons I don’t feel like explaining. I removed that part of the app. Shouldn’t display anymore, but let me know if I’m wrong).
“Also, i find it a bit odd that there is a "Staff" award when you can already tell who is part of the staff because of the thing below their name” – Charmanderson (TAY: Yeah, the badge looks pretty crappy, too. The idea behind that was as follows: make badges to honor current and former staff. Now that I think about it, I probably should just delete the “current staff” award and only make a “Emeritus Staff” award. The current staff award is redundant, you’re right.”
@Kaguya – Yeah, I’m sorry. I didn’t mean any harm by it. I’ll change it
IMPORTANT LIMITATIONS RIGHT NOW
Right now I’m trying to find a way to let users choose which awards show up on post view (under your user info when you post on the site), but I’m not having much success. That might come later. For now we may be stuck with a “these are the latest awards given to this member” sort of approach.
My ability to auto-award posts is very limited atm. They’re all done pretty much by hand. Thus I’m going to need to hold off on awards like, “Joined the site in 2012” or “Posted 200 times in the Introduce Yourself forum”. It would quickly become a full-time job to identify everybody who qualified.
AND A FEW MORE IDEAS
One award idea I’d like to try is allowing certain members of the community to hand out awards. For example, if Batman is interested, he could be the guinea pig and could come up with an award idea – pass it by me – and then abuse you poor souls until you earn it. He’d let me know when somebody earned the award, and then I’d grant it. (Actual offer, Batman. Let me know.) (You’ll need to make your own icon, though)
Thanks to everybody who wants me to have an award! I decided to wait on that because A) Self-congratulations is tacky , and B) There are dozens and dozens of people who deserve their own award. I figure if I don’t have an award, they won’t feel quite so left out. Once life slows down I’ll work on adding more unique awards! (Also, I’d be interested if anyone had ideas for ways to “qualify” for having your own award. Maybe a list of requirements like post count, time on the forums, good looks, and swearing fealty to myself? Maybe not all those things, but I’d absolutely be up for a method for users to earn their own award)
I mentioned that I don’t know when the “choose which trophies to display” functionality will work. Until then, are we okay with just showing the last six? Did you want to do fewer? More?
Aaaah. Somehow, coming from Beato, this stings worst of all…
; P