Introduction
Thank you to those quoted in my spoiler for the analysis! Very helpful! I've quoted theme here for easy access so newcomers don't need to necessarily read the entire 3 pages of discussion.
We've been discussing this since time immemorial (usually in conjunction with another proposal: review sub-forums, like this proposal), but discussion was mainly kept in the staff forum. Now that we have the improvement board, I'm glad to see the wider community engaging with the idea. I guess that means this board is doing what it's supposed to ; ). Before I move on, I'll repeat again that the main idea behind minimizing the number of boards is to centralize discussion.
Here's the forums' current arrangement:
More Thoughts
The proposals made so far are good, but they're not the only options. In our current theme we have the ability to utilize tags. We could start implementing stricter control of tag use (random examples could include: "VN Review", "Anime Review", "VN Recommendation", etc.) and even put links to them in sidebars. It would require everybody to start paying attention to tags, but we'd quickly adjust. (A good example: after I implemented the "My Followed Topics" sidebar, the "Follow" function has increased ~450%)
That said, many people are for some sort of sub-board. Because we're a VN site (and we already distinguish VN talk from General talk), I don't think a combined VN/Otaku recommendation forum makes a lot of sense. It makes more sense to me to embed "Recommendations" sub-forums in both the "VN Talk" and "Anime/Manga" boards (or in just one of them, etc.). If precedent matters (which it probably doesn't), the "Games and Chatter" sub-forum (which was an evolution of the IRC sub-forum) was put into place because "chatter" posts became unwieldy. If many members feel such is the case with recommendation threads, then I'd understand the logical precedent.
Now, assuming we want sub-forums, let's discuss the two key points:
How do we make sure these new boards will be used often and in a meaningful way?
How do we make sure they don't harm the overall VN/Otaku boards? If we make (a) subforum(s), would we want to open it up to more than just recommendations? What about reviews?
My Opinion
I think the tag idea is interesting, and I think we should investigate ways it could be used effectively. That would certainly be part of this discussion, but clever people who want to think of ideas are welcome to make a new thread for this.
Otherwise, I'll put in my two cents for the two questions I raised about sub-forums:
1. How do we make sure these new boards will be used often and in a meaningful way?
What about merging this idea with review board proposals? Make "Reviews and Recommendations" sub-forums inside the "VN Talk" and maybe the "Anime/Manga" boards.
One idea Steve brought up was to encourage people to spice up their posts (star systems, pictures, etc.). Variety is the spice of life -- do we all agree that we should encourage this?
If we have recommendation sub-forums, we absolutely need to highlight Clephas and Kaguya's posts. I'd go so far as to suggest we pin them all.
The big question: will there be enough traffic to these new boards to warrant their creation? As I mentioned above, I suspect that by creating these boards, traffic will increase as people see the opportunity.
2. How do we make sure they don't harm the overall VN/Otaku boards? If we make (a) subforum(s), would we want to open it up to more than just recommendations? What about reviews?
Will removing recommendation threads harm activity in the main boards? Would removing recommendation threads AND review threads? I don't think so, but I don't always have a lot of time to read the entire board. I'd love to hear everybody else's opinions.
Thanks, everybody! Sorry for the wall of text, but now that I'm healthy and my brain is clear, I thought I'd try and add a few more dimensions to the conversation.