So, I've been playing a bunch of midrange secret paladin today after getting sick of facing them with my control warrior.
Went alright, but then I ran into a bunch of tempo mages and patrons for the last 15 or so games. So, about par for the course of the average laddering experience.
As an aside, I've also been playing just a regular midrange paladin list too. I haven't seen it discussed too much, but it seems regular midrange paladin is favored in the secret paladin matchup. You can handily diffuse christmas trees with aldor/equality/consecrates. Am I wrong in thinking this?