(I love this topic idea. Well, well done) (Edit: And we know it's going to be a great discussion because, after all, a Luck Dragon debuted on post #4 ; ))
My Second Visual Novel - Fate Route
When I finished Fate/Stay Night (Fate route), I sat back from my computer, turned off the speakers (the menu music was playing), and struggled to breathe through minor heartbreak and tear-blurred eyes. Phrases like, "Wow..." and "How did they do that?" floated through my mind. My heart ached for Saber (and all the characters, really), and I kept replaying the last few scenes in my head. My thoughts then went to, "How and why did that so powerfully affect me?" I thought a lot about Saber, and how she embodied a lot of the things I loved most about my wife.
It was ~4:45 in the morning, my wife was asleep but soon to be waking, and so I remember slipping into the bedroom, snuggling up to her and kissing the back of her head.
And then I fell asleep.
What followed was 2-3 days of wondering whether or not I wanted to immediately continue on to the next F/SN game route (I ultimately waited two weeks), and then after lunch I started Sharin no Kuni.